What is Remembering?

There were certain words that changed the temperature of a room.

Love was one. Death was another. God, occasionally.

But remembering had always seemed to Prashaila more dangerous than all three.

She found Nishelle beneath the old mango tree beyond the Temple of Ether, sitting barefoot in the grass with a book open across her thighs and absolutely no intention of reading it. The pages had been left to the wind. Every few seconds one lifted, turned, and settled again, as though the book had become bored with waiting for her.

Prashaila stopped a few feet away.

“You’re thinking.”

Nishelle looked up. “That’s a terrible accusation.”

“You have the face.”

“What face?”

“The one you make when you’ve discovered something inconvenient and are deciding whether knowing it has improved your life.”

Nishelle considered this. “It hasn’t.”

“Then you’ve definitely discovered something.”

Nishelle closed the book. For a while neither woman spoke.

The Temple was unusually quiet that afternoon. Light moved through the trees in long, pale columns, catching dust in the air and turning it briefly visible. Somewhere beyond the garden, water ran over stone. The sound was almost imperceptible, but once noticed it became impossible not to hear.

Nishelle looked at her.

“Do you ever think we’re all trying to remember something?”

Prashaila smiled faintly.

“Everyone?”

“Humans.”

“That is rather a lot of people to accuse.”

“I’m serious.”

“So am I.”

Nishelle shifted against the tree.

“Then what are they trying to remember?”

Prashaila looked towards the Temple.

“That is the question.”

“No. That’s the irritating answer.”

Prashaila laughed. Nishelle pointed at her. “There. You do that.”

“Do what?”

“You make everything sound like it belongs on a stone tablet.”

“I’ve been told it’s charming.”

“By whom?”

“Shaurya.”

Nishelle groaned.

“Oh, no.”

“What?”

“You’ve brought him into it.”

“He was already in it.”

“He usually is.”

Prashaila tried not to smile. She failed. That was the first thing about Shaurya that made him dangerous. He had a way of becoming present even when he wasn’t there, as though the mind had its own private architecture and had inconveniently reserved one of the larger rooms for him.

Nishelle watched her expression change.

“That’s exactly what I mean.”

“What?”

“You thought of him and something happened to your face.”

“My face is perfectly normal.”

“Your face has never been normal around that man.”

Prashaila looked away. Nishelle smiled.

“Interesting.”

“Don’t.”

“I haven’t said anything.”

“You’re about to.”

“I was merely observing.”

“That’s Elvira’s word.”

“And now you’ve made this scientific.”

Prashaila sighed. Nishelle leaned closer.

“Have you ever remembered something because of him?”

The question landed differently. Prashaila’s amusement disappeared.

“Yes.”

Nishelle waited.

“Not a memory of him,” Prashaila said eventually. “A memory of myself.”

The wind moved through the branches above them. Nishelle lowered her voice.

“What did you remember?”

Prashaila looked down at her hands.

“That I had forgotten.”

Nishelle frowned.

“That isn’t an answer.”

“It is the only honest one.”

She stood and began walking slowly through the garden. Nishelle followed.

“I think that’s what people misunderstand about remembering,” Prashaila said. “They imagine it means recovering information. A name. A face. A place. Something that happened on a Tuesday when you were seventeen.”

“And it isn’t?”

“Sometimes.”

“What is it then?”

Prashaila stopped beside the fountain. She watched the water fall.

“Sometimes remembering is recognising something that your mind has never been given permission to know.”

Nishelle stared at her.

“That sounds impossible.”

“So does dreaming.”

“Dreaming is scientifically explainable.”

“Most things are explainable after they’ve stopped frightening us.”

Nishelle smiled despite herself.

“You really do enjoy doing that.”

“Doing what?”

“Making me regret asking questions.”

Prashaila dipped her fingers into the fountain. The water was cold.

“Humans spend their entire lives accumulating information,” she said. “Names. Dates. Faces. Instructions. Wounds. Desires. They call this memory.”

“And it isn’t?”

“It is one kind.”

She lifted her hand and let the water run from her fingertips.

“But there is another kind.”

Nishelle waited.

“The memory of what you were before you became so convinced you were yourself.”

The sentence settled between them. Nishelle looked at her for a long moment.

“That sounds frightening.”

“It can be.”

“Why?”

“Because identity is comfortable.”

“Comfortable?”

“Even when it hurts.”

Nishelle understood. She looked down. People held onto themselves in strange ways. They defended old versions of themselves long after those versions had become prisons. They kept stories about who they were because the stories gave their lives edges. They said I am this and I am not that and slowly built a person out of exclusions.

The remembering, perhaps, was what happened when those walls became transparent.

“When people remember,” Nishelle said quietly, “what do they become?”

Prashaila turned towards her.

“Less certain.”

“That sounds terrible.”

“It can also be freedom.”

“Those are suspiciously similar.”

“They are.”

Nishelle laughed.

“Fine. Then what are humans actually trying to remember?”

Prashaila didn’t answer immediately. She looked beyond the garden, towards the mountains.

“Themselves.”

Nishelle waited.

“That sounds simple.”

“It isn’t.”

“What part of themselves?”

“The part that existed before the explanation.”

Nishelle’s brow furrowed. Prashaila continued gently.

“Before the name. Before the family. Before the fear. Before someone told you what kind of person you were. Before you learned which desires were acceptable and which ones had to be buried. Before you became fluent in your own limitations.”

Nishelle’s expression softened.

“So the remembering is about going backwards.”

“No.”

“Then forwards?”

“No.”

Prashaila smiled.

“It is about becoming quiet enough that you can hear what was there before either direction mattered.”

Nishelle stared at her.

“You know, when normal people talk about memory, they use words like childhood.”

“I know.”

“It’s much less exhausting.”

“Probably.”

“And considerably less attractive.”

Prashaila laughed.

“I’m not sure memory is supposed to be attractive.”

“Everything becomes attractive if Shaurya is standing nearby.”

Prashaila turned. Nishelle was grinning.

“You… ”

“You are avoiding the question.”

“What question?”

“Why does Shaurya make you remember?”

The garden suddenly seemed warmer. Prashaila looked towards the path.

“He doesn’t.”

Nishelle raised an eyebrow.

“He doesn’t?”

“He makes it harder to forget.”

That silenced her. Because there was a difference. A profound one. Forgetting could be deliberate. Necessary. Protective. It could be something the mind did without permission, or something the soul seemed to do for reasons the conscious self could not understand.

But sometimes another person entered your life and made forgetting impossible. Not because they knew your history. Because something in you recognised something in them. Nishelle spoke carefully.

“And what do you remember when you’re near him?”

Prashaila smiled. This time there was something almost embarrassed in it.

“Heat.”

Nishelle’s eyes widened.

“That’s remarkably specific.”

“I didn’t say where.”

“You didn’t need to.”

Prashaila gave her a look. Nishelle laughed.

“Fine. Fine. Continue.”

Prashaila shook her head, but she was smiling now.

“He makes me remember what it feels like to be completely awake.”

The humour faded.

“And that,” she said, “is much more dangerous.”

A voice came from behind them.

“I’ve been told I’m dangerous.”

They turned. Shaurya stood at the entrance to the garden. He looked as though he’d been there long enough to hear considerably more than either woman would have preferred. His sleeves were rolled to his forearms. His hair was untidy from the wind. There was something infuriatingly calm about him, the kind of calm that made other people aware of their own breathing.

Nishelle looked at Prashaila. Prashaila looked at Shaurya. Shaurya looked at both of them.

“Should I come back?”

“No,” Nishelle said immediately.

Prashaila gave her a murderous look.

“What?” Nishelle said. “I’m interested in the research.”

Shaurya smiled. That smile was a problem. It wasn’t broad or theatrical. It was the smallest movement at the corner of his mouth, the private amusement of someone who had just discovered he was being discussed by two women and had decided to enjoy himself.

“What were you remembering?” he asked.

“Nothing,” Prashaila said.

“Interesting.”

“You’re not helping.”

“I wasn’t aware I was required to.”

Nishelle looked between them. There was suddenly far too much electricity in the garden.

“You two are exhausting.”

Shaurya walked towards them. Prashaila held his gaze. Neither moved. He stopped close enough that she could feel the warmth of him without being touched. That was the thing about desire. It did not require contact. Sometimes the anticipation was more intimate than the act itself. Shaurya lowered his voice.

“What do you remember?”

Prashaila’s eyes didn’t leave his.

“I don’t know yet.”

Something changed in his expression. Not fear. Recognition. Nishelle noticed it. So did Prashaila. And suddenly the conversation was no longer theoretical. Shaurya looked at her as though she had just said something he had been waiting years to hear.

Nishelle cleared her throat.

“Well.”

Neither of them looked at her.

“I’m going to leave.”

Still nothing. She took three steps. Then stopped.

“Actually, before I go, I have one question.”

Shaurya finally looked away from Prashaila. Nishelle smiled sweetly.

“What exactly are humans remembering?”

Shaurya’s expression became unreadable. Prashaila waited. He looked at the fountain.Then the Temple. Then back at her.

“The thing they knew before they were taught to forget it.”

Nishelle went very still. Prashaila’s heart gave one hard beat. Shaurya continued.

“That they were never as separate as they thought.”

No one spoke. The garden seemed suddenly enormous. The water fell. The trees moved. Somewhere in the distance, a bird called once and then stopped.

Nishelle looked at Prashaila. Prashaila looked at Shaurya. And something inside her shifted. Not a memory. Not exactly. More like the outline of one.

A room. A different sky. Shaurya’s hand at the back of her neck. His mouth against her temple. His voice saying something she could not quite hear.

Then nothing. She blinked. Shaurya had gone pale. He knew. He had seen it happen.

“You remembered,” he said.

Prashaila swallowed.

“Something.”

Nishelle looked between them.

“What?”

Neither answered. Because suddenly they both understood the uncomfortable truth. The remembering was not necessarily the recovery of the past. It might be the moment when something buried inside consciousness recognised itself in the present.

A person. A place. A feeling. A choice. A love.

Something could remain forgotten for centuries and still exert a quiet pressure on the life being lived above it. Humans called this intuition.

Déjà vu.

Longing.

Fate.

Attraction.

Grief without an object.

The strange certainty that somewhere, sometime, they had been here before. Perhaps all of those experiences were different names for the same phenomenon. Perhaps the human mind was not trying to remember a particular event at all. Perhaps it was trying to remember wholeness. And perhaps that was why people spent their lives searching.

They searched for lovers. They searched for God. They searched for home. They searched for themselves.

They travelled across continents, changed careers, destroyed perfectly respectable lives, fell in love with inappropriate people, wrote books, built temples, stared into mirrors, meditated in caves, danced until dawn and occasionally made catastrophically poor decisions involving someone else’s fiancé.

They called the search by thousands of names. But beneath all of them was the same hunger.

I know there is something I have forgotten.

And somewhere deep inside them was an even stranger conviction.

When I find it, I will know.

Prashaila looked at Shaurya. He was still watching her. There was desire there, certainly. Something hot and unmistakably human. But beneath it was something else.

Recognition.

Not of her face. Of her. And suddenly she understood why remembering could be frightening. Because if you remembered enough, you might discover that the person you had spent your entire life trying to become was only a temporary arrangement.

A costume. A useful name. A beautiful little lie. And underneath it was something older.

Something quieter. Something that had been waiting. Nishelle broke the silence.

“So we’re all basically walking around with amnesia?”

Shaurya looked at her.

“That’s one interpretation.”

“That’s terrible.”

“It’s also funny.”

“How?”

“Because everyone keeps looking for themselves while carrying themselves around all day.”

Nishelle considered that.

“That’s annoyingly good.”

“I know.”

Prashaila laughed. Shaurya looked at her. For a moment neither of them spoke. Then she stepped closer. Not enough to touch. Enough to make the distance between them feel deliberate.

“Do you remember everything?” she asked.

His expression changed.

“No.”

“What do you remember?”

He looked at her mouth. Then back into her eyes.

“Enough to know I shouldn’t tell you.”

Prashaila smiled. It wasn’t sweet. It was curious. Dangerously so.

“Then perhaps,” she whispered, “you should stop trying to stop me.”

For once, Shaurya had no clever answer. Nishelle looked at the sky.

“Oh, wonderful.”

They both glanced at her. She sighed.

“I came here to discuss consciousness and somehow ended up watching two people flirt with metaphysics.”

Prashaila laughed. Shaurya smiled. And Nishelle shook her head as she walked away. Behind her, the fountain kept falling. Neither Prashaila nor Shaurya noticed that the water had begun running backwards.

Not dramatically. Not enough to be called impossible. Just enough that, if either of them had been paying attention, they might have wondered whether the garden had briefly forgotten which direction time was supposed to move.

But perhaps that was what the remembering was. Not going backwards. Not recovering what had been lost. Perhaps it was simply the moment consciousness became quiet enough to recognise something it had never truly forgotten.

And perhaps that was why humans kept searching.

Why they fell in love with people who felt strangely familiar. Why certain places made their skin prickle. Why a song could open a room that had been locked for twenty years. Why a stranger’s eyes could occasionally make the heart behave as though it had been waiting.

They weren’t always looking for something new. Sometimes they were looking for the thing they had known before they knew how to name it. And perhaps the cruellest, most beautiful part was this: They would never know they had found it until they remembered.